Nov 5–12, 2026 · OʻahuKoa Challenge Veteran Games
Get involved
Big Tire Bootcamp — Spartan DEKA AffiliateAMVETS
CallFree 7-Day Pass
Mindset · 9 min read

Why People Don't Do What They Say They'll Do: A Coach's Answer

By Coach Alim · 11/12/2026

One of my coaches pulled me aside this week with a simple question. A group that trains with us had confirmed they were coming last week and then didn't show. It was a scheduling error on their end, and they apologized. Now they had confirmed again for this week. "Coach, are they actually coming?"

I started to answer the way you would expect. They have been with us almost four years. They said they're coming. They have every reason to come. Then I stopped halfway through the sentence, because the honest answer is that I don't know. Neither does anyone else. After more than 30 years of coaching, I still cannot tell you for certain what another human being is going to do.

That question has fascinated me for most of my life: why do people do, or not do, what they say they're going to do? This post is my answer. It covers what the research says, two stories from my own career that cost me something, and the shift that took a question which used to wear me out and turned it into peace.

Key Takeaways
  • ›Saying you will do something and doing it are two separate events; research suggests nearly half of people who intend to exercise don't follow through.
  • ›The best predictor of what someone will do is what they have repeatedly done, but a strong track record is a probability, not a promise.
  • ›Money, status, and credentials do not buy commitment; people routinely pay for things they never use.
  • ›Specific plans close the gap: naming when and where you will act roughly doubled follow-through in one classic exercise study.
  • ›Coaches who measure their own inputs (preparation, invitation, effort) instead of other people's choices stay motivated for decades instead of burning out.

The Question Behind the Question

Let me give you the background on this group, because it matters. They have trained with us for close to four years, once a week, which works out to roughly 200 sessions. In all that time they have had exactly one scheduling conflict where they said they were coming and didn't. That is about 99.5 percent attendance. Most gyms would kill for that number from their paying members.

It is also a group made up of people in addiction recovery. People in recovery plan ahead because they have to. Their days are built on structure, accountability, and keeping their word one day at a time. I don't believe for a second that last week's miss was intentional. Someone got a calendar wrong, the way all of us have at some point.

The research is on my side here, too. A well-known review by Ouellette and Wood found that past behavior, especially behavior repeated in a stable setting, predicts future behavior better than what people say they intend. By that standard, a group that has shown up 199 times out of 200 is a very good bet.

But a good bet is still a bet. That is what stopped me mid-sentence. I could give my coach the odds, but I could not give him an answer, and I realized I had spent years of my life acting like I could.

The Gap Between Saying and Doing Is Bigger Than You Think

Psychologists have a name for this: the intention-behavior gap. In a major review, Paschal Sheeran found that intentions explain only about 28 percent of the variation in what people actually do. In exercise specifically, a meta-analysis by Rhodes and de Bruijn found that close to half of people who intended to be active did not follow through.

It gets more striking. When researchers deliberately raised people's intentions in experiments, Webb and Sheeran found that a medium-to-large change in intention produced only a small-to-medium change in behavior. You can talk somebody all the way into wanting it and still not get them to the field.

Part of the reason is that we are terrible at forecasting our own time. In the classic planning fallacy study, students estimated they would finish their theses in about 34 days on average. It actually took them about 56 days, and only around 30 percent finished by the date they predicted. Another part is that so much of life runs on autopilot: one diary study estimated that about 43 percent of everyday actions are habits, done in the same place while thinking about something else.

None of this is new. The Apostle Paul described the intention-behavior gap almost two thousand years ago: "For the good that I would I do not: but the evil which I would not, that I do" (Romans 7:19). If Paul struggled to do what he said he would do, I should probably stop being shocked when my clients do too.

How I Burned Myself Out Taking It Personally

When I was a younger coach, I nearly burned out on coaching, and this exact question was the reason. I would sit with someone, give them everything I knew about training, nutrition, and recovery, and tell them with full confidence, "This will work for you." Then they wouldn't do it. And I would get hurt.

I took it as a personal attack. I thought, I gave you my best, and you threw it away. I would lose sleep, pour more energy into the next client to prove a point, and get burned again. It was an endless cycle, because there was no reliable way to predict who would follow through. The eager ones quit. The quiet ones I had written off turned into my best success stories. Every theory I came up with fell apart.

Motivation research explains why I kept losing. Self-determination theory, one of the most studied frameworks in psychology, shows that lasting motivation depends on autonomy: people stick with what they choose for themselves. A coach can support that choice, but cannot install it. The harder I tried to control the outcome, the more I was working against the very thing that makes change stick.

I was keeping score in a game where I didn't control the ball. No wonder I was tired.

The $5,000-a-Month Client Who Never Launched

Fast forward to the height of online training after COVID. I ran a high-end, done-for-you men's optimization program, and you had to qualify to get in. The average client earned around $250,000 a year. It cost $5,000 a month with a 12-month minimum, because that is how long it really takes to optimize a man. These were physicians, attorneys, and business owners, people with a lot more money than time.

We did nearly everything. Custom training, custom nutrition, a weekly call, lab work, and a partner physician providing concierge care. The only things we couldn't do were eat their food and lift their weights. There were no refunds, by design. We burned the boats. If you signed up, you were committing, and most of these men delivered. The habits that made them successful in their careers carried straight over into their training, and their results were outstanding.

Except for one man. Every check-in had a lapse. You could tell he wasn't doing the work. He never asked for his money back, never complained, and honestly never seemed to care. The year came and went, and he never got close to what he was capable of. I finally realized what was happening. In every other area of his life he could trade money for time or money for results. Fitness is one of the few places where that trade doesn't work. You cannot buy a six-pack. Even the most expensive chemicals in the world still require someone to do the reps.

Economists have documented the same thing. In a study titled Paying Not to Go to the Gym, members on monthly contracts paid over $70 a month but went only about four times, roughly $17 a visit, when a $10 pay-per-visit option was available. And in the famous sunk cost study with theater season tickets, people who paid full price attended more shows than people who got a discount, but only in the first half of the season. After that, the difference disappeared. Money can buy attention for a while. It cannot buy follow-through.

Man Will Fail. That Was Never My Assignment.

Here is what changed for me, and it isn't a technique. Now that I'm older, I understand that it was never about what man will do. Man will always fail at some point. Jesus said it plainly: "the spirit indeed is willing, but the flesh is weak" (Matthew 26:41). That includes my clients, my coaches, and me.

God was never asking me to watch those vanity metrics. He was never asking me to predict who would show up, who would do the program, or who would keep their word. Scripture is honest about how little we know: "ye know not what shall be on the morrow" (James 4:14). What He does is instruct me, daily, to build. To create. To invite. To do the specific work He put in front of me. What each person does with that invitation is between them and Him.

Paul put it in terms any coach can understand: "I have planted, Apollos watered; but God gave the increase" (1 Corinthians 3:6). In the parable of the sower, the farmer scatters seed on every kind of ground, and the soil decides what grows. The sower's job is to keep sowing. So when I catch myself worrying about whether someone is going to do what I think they should, I get corrected, and the correction sounds like this: That's not what I asked you to do. I'll handle the rest. You do what I told you.

That is why I'm at peace with so much of my life now. We build. We set things up. We invite and we create. If people come, that's wonderful. If they don't, we keep moving forward. A no-show isn't an insult, and a client who quits isn't a verdict on my worth. I work "heartily, as to the Lord, and not unto men" (Colossians 3:23), and that has given me more energy at this stage of my career than I ever had when I was trying to control everyone else's choices.

What I Actually Told My Coach, and What You Can Do With This

So here is the answer I finally gave: "I don't know if they'll come. Nobody does. Based on four years, I'd bet on them. Set the field up like they're coming. If they show, we give them a great session. If they don't, we coach whoever is standing in front of us just as hard." From a scheduling standpoint, a miss is frustrating. We value people's time, and our coaches give up theirs to be there. That frustration is real and worth addressing with a phone call. But it has almost no effect on my motivation, energy, or effort anymore, because those were never tied to someone else's attendance.

If you coach, lead, or parent, here is the practical side. Confirm with specifics, not just a yes. In a classic exercise study by Milne, Orbell and Sheeran, 91 percent of people who wrote down exactly when and where they would exercise did it at least once a week, compared with about 35 to 38 percent of the other groups. Psychologists call this an implementation intention, and across nearly 100 studies Gollwitzer and Sheeran found it consistently improves follow-through.

Then measure what you control. Did I prepare? Did I invite? Did I coach the person in front of me with everything I had? Did I follow up? Those are the metrics that keep a coach going for thirty years. Use a track record to set expectations, not to feel entitled to anything. And treat a scheduling miss as a logistics problem to solve, not a character judgment to carry around.

And if you are the one who keeps saying you're going to start, I'm not mad at you. Give yourself an implementation intention right now: Tuesday, Wednesday, or Thursday at 5:30 PM, or Saturday at 6:00 AM, at Warrior Field on the West Oahu Veterans Center grounds in Ewa Beach. Check the schedule, read how long it takes to see results, and if you need a reason that goes deeper than the mirror, read why I still work out when healthy people die early. Veterans and active duty train free. Claim your FREE 7-day pass at Warrior Field, and wherever you are in the world, check out our app at btbstrong.com for free tools and resources to help you get better no matter where you're starting from. We'll have the field set up either way.

Frequently Asked Questions

Why do people say they will do something and then not do it?
Most people mean it when they say it. The problem is the intention-behavior gap: intentions explain only a modest share of what people actually do. Habits, competing demands, scheduling conflicts, and plain optimism about future time (the planning fallacy) all get between the promise and the action. It is usually human, not personal.
What is the intention-behavior gap?
It is the distance between what people intend to do and what they actually do. In exercise research, a meta-analysis by Rhodes and de Bruijn found that close to half of people who intended to be active did not follow through. Experiments show that even large changes in intention produce much smaller changes in behavior.
How do coaches stop taking client no-shows personally?
Separate your job from their choice. Your job is to prepare, invite, coach well, and follow up. Whether someone shows up belongs to them. Track the things you control, confirm sessions with specific times and places, plan each class to work for whoever is there, and handle scheduling problems as logistics rather than as a verdict on you.
What is the best predictor of whether someone will follow through?
Past behavior in a stable routine is the strongest single predictor, stronger than what people say they intend. Someone who has trained every Tuesday for years will probably be there next Tuesday. Even so, it is a probability, not a guarantee, so plan as if they are coming and stay ready if they are not.
Field Notes Weekly

One of these in your inbox every Wednesday

One idea you can use in your next session, drawn from this library. Free, and one click to leave whenever you want.

Keep Reading
Ready?

Your First Week
Is FREE.

No card. No commitment. Just show up and find out what you're made of.

Then it's simple: $59/mo single · $99/mo standard family · Veterans & active duty FREE, with a $59/mo add-on for their family — cancel anytime.